In 2014, Ed Sheeran’s hit song “Thinking Out Loud” became a chart-topping success. However, in 2016, the song was accused of copyright infringement by the estate of Marvin Gaye, specifically his classic soul song “Let’s Get It On.” The case went to trial, and the verdict was a controversial one.
The lawsuit claimed that Sheeran’s song copied the melody, harmony, and rhythm of Gaye’s song. The estate of Gaye argued that the two songs were substantially similar and that Sheeran had copied Gaye’s work without permission. Sheeran, on the other hand, argued that he had not copied Gaye’s song and that any similarities were coincidental.
During the trial, musicologists were called upon to analyze the two songs and determine whether there was copyright infringement. The musicologists testified that there were similarities between the two songs, but they disagreed on whether those similarities constituted copyright infringement.
Ultimately, the jury found in favor of Gaye’s estate and awarded them $5 million in damages. The verdict was controversial because it set a precedent for copyright cases involving music. Some argued that the verdict was too harsh and could stifle creativity in the music industry. Others argued that it was a necessary step to protect the intellectual property of artists.
The case also raised questions about the nature of creativity and originality in music. Many songs are inspired by other songs or use similar chord progressions or melodies. It can be difficult to draw a line between inspiration and infringement.
In the aftermath of the trial, many artists have become more cautious about their use of other artists’ work. Some have even gone so far as to seek permission from other artists before using their work in their own songs.
Overall, the copyright trial between Ed Sheeran’s hit song “Thinking Out Loud” and Marvin Gaye’s classic soul song “Let’s Get It On” was a controversial and groundbreaking case. It highlighted the importance of protecting intellectual property in the music industry and raised questions about the nature of creativity and originality in music.
