As Title 42, a public health order that allowed the United States to expel migrants at the southern border during the COVID-19 pandemic, expired on October 1st, 2021, President Joe Biden’s actions have come under scrutiny. Many are questioning whether his current actions contradict his previous criticism of former President Donald Trump’s immigration policies.
During his campaign, Biden promised to reverse Trump’s immigration policies and create a more humane approach to immigration. He criticized Trump’s use of Title 42, calling it a “cruel” policy that violated human rights. However, as president, Biden continued to use Title 42 to expel migrants at the border, even as the pandemic situation improved.
Biden’s administration has defended the use of Title 42, stating that it is necessary to protect public health and prevent the spread of COVID-19. However, many human rights organizations and immigration advocates have criticized the policy, stating that it violates international law and puts vulnerable migrants at risk.
As Title 42 expired, Biden’s administration announced that they would no longer use the policy to expel families and unaccompanied minors. However, they stated that single adults would still be subject to expulsion under Title 42.
Critics argue that this decision is contradictory to Biden’s promises to create a more humane approach to immigration. They argue that expelling single adults puts them at risk of violence and persecution in their home countries and that it does not align with Biden’s values of compassion and human rights.
Additionally, some have pointed out that Biden’s administration has continued to use other harsh immigration policies, such as detention and deportation. They argue that these policies also contradict Biden’s promises to create a more humane approach to immigration.
Overall, examining Biden’s actions as Title 42 expires raises important questions about his commitment to his campaign promises and values. While some may argue that the use of Title 42 was necessary during the pandemic, others argue that it violated human rights and put vulnerable migrants at risk. As Biden’s administration moves forward with its immigration policies, it will be important to continue to examine whether they align with his promises and values.
